Saving Sunshine by Saadia Faruqi illustrated by Shazleen Khan
The themes, messaging and Islamic and cultural representation in this upper MG/lower middle school graphic novel are wonderfully unapologetically present. Yet somehow, I never connected with the characters, and the plotting seemed stiff. I don’t regret reading the book, and I’m sure most readers will be delighted with the main story of sibling annoyance, a sick turtle, and independent kids with reflective flashbacks and OWN voice threads of Islamophobia, immigration, starting to wear hijab, identity and othering. I just felt the tropes were predictable, stereotypical even, and when the dad takes a stethoscope to a medical conference and the TSA agent doesn’t know what it is, I cringed. Seriously, who takes a stethoscope on vacation? Who doesn’t know what one is? I normally love the author’s characters and wish for more Islam, this book gave me the Islam, but I really disliked the siblings, they were mean, angry, and annoying. I own that reading a book about bickering kids a few days before my own five children returned to school may have jaded me, and I do think I found the religious touchstones predictable because I do read a lot of kid lit and I’m older, so while I’m not gushing in my praise for this book, I will be preordering a copy for myself and the school library. How is that for having an opinion and then completely walking it back? Yeah, it happens.
SYNOPSIS:
Twins Zara and Zeeshan bicker, a lot. Zara loves animals and nature, Zeeshan space exploration, and both love their phones. When the family heads to a medical conference in Key West where their mom is getting an award, the kids get their phones taken away by their parents when the two won’t stop fighting. The parents stick to their policy and the two are forced to stick together and entertain themselves while their parents attend lectures. At one point they find a turtle and Zara takes the lead to try and help Sunshine, but will need her brother along the way.
WHY I LIKE IT:
I love that the characters identifying as Muslim was central and unapologetic. I liked the flashbacks that provided a little bit of depth to the parents coming to America and their life in Pakistan, along with the personal reflections about starting to wearing hijab and when the kids started to go their own way. But the airport scene, the identity issues, and the Islamophobia seemed a little superficial and over done. The heart to hearts with the dad and his son and mom and Zara were sweet and insightful about belonging and where you come from, and not being so angry, but they also seemed very natural and in-character for the parents which is a disconnect from the anger the kids seem to carry. If the parents are talking to them and modeling all this, it is a bit of a stretch that they are reacting as they are in the book.
I have a brother, it is just the two of us, we aren’t twins, but growing up in the 80s as the only Muslims in the area with a convert mom and immigrant dad, we came together a lot because only each other could understand the stresses we faced in and outside our home. I thought this book would draw on that universal theme, and I was surprised that the point of the book felt a little underdeveloped. I know MG can handle more than we give them credit for, but I felt like this book built up to have more of a warm hug, than I felt. I wanted more of them plotting together, I didn’t feel like Zara really needed her brother to stick up for her, she wanted it sure, but that was a foot in the door that I think was missed. She is strong, yet was being vulnerable with her brother, and he was able to step up for her, but it needed a few more beats to be appreciated. I also wanted more connection to the turtle, his name is in the title, I thought he’d have a bigger role.
FLAGS:
Disrespect, lying, anger, yelling, bullying, teasing, Islamophobia, stereotypes, prejudice
TOOLS FOR LEADING THE DISCUSSION:
The book would allow for discussion for middle grade readers who might see themselves in the family dynamic or be able to relate to some of the Islamophobia. It could also cause some worry for some children that being visibly Muslim or having cultural names, and wearing cultural clothes will bring negative differential treatment to them.
Available for order here
