Festivals and Celebrations: Eid al-Fitr by Louise Nelson
This non fiction Eid book is not accurate, detailed, engaging, or something I would recommend schools or libraries shelve. It used to baffle me, but it now infuriates me that books like this continue to be published as non fiction, when they unfortunately perpetuate many of the same errors of similar earlier books, Muslim beta and sensitivity readers exist, why do publishers not seek them and out? At least Google the subject before you write and publish a book.
Lets begin with my favorite: Muslims fast because Allah swt has commanded it, yes it helps us “become closer to Allah,” but it is not so that we, “understand what it is like to not have enough food.” Sure that might be a resulting lesson, but it is not the reason. It states that “children and people who are old, pregnant or ill do not fast during Ramadan,” which isn’t always true and needs clarifying to say they may not be “required” to fast. Many children do fast, many pregnant women fast, by simplifying it to such a degree, students fasting may feel less seen when presumably reading a book like this in a school, classroom, or library setting. The exact places meant to help provide windows and mirrors and foster understanding and an inclusive environment.
Eid al Fitr is celebrated on the first of Shawwal, some countries, cultures, or families may extend the festivities for three days, but unlike Eid al Adha, Eid al Fitr is only one day. There is nothing about white being a holy color and there are no requirements to wear white on Eid.
The brief history of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ receiving the revelation from Angel Jibreel would be even better with proper salawat and respect given. It also seems to imply that he traveled far and wide spreading the message and became a Prophet all within the month of Ramadan. It completely erroneously states that “Muslims remember the meeting of Muhammad and Jibreel and the writing of the Qur’an by fasting during Ramadan.” How does remembering translate to fasting? Muslims make an extra effort to read more Qur’an in Ramadan, as blessings are multiplied, but the causation is incorrect.
The information about Zakat and charity is vague, not clarifying that Zakat al Fitr is required on all to pay not just adults. Unfortunately it clearly mistakenly states that Eid prayers is prayed, “just after sunrise.” It is not, it is prayed in the morning, but not “just after sunrise.” The phrasing about Muslims reciting prayers together to feel closer to Allah also seems off, why not just say Eid prayers are prayed in congregation. And while sure in some places the community might eat together after the khutbah, it doesn’t happen everywhere and is not required, nor is eating sheer-khurma. That is simply one of many sweet dishes made in the sub continent that has no religious role whatsoever. The remainder of the book is poorly written. “people play games and eat.” It then says that Eid is celebrated in many different countries because Muslims live all around the world, but only gives one example that “in Turkey, baklava is given as presents.” That does not show people in different countries all over the world, the legit, shows one country.
How is this terrible writing making it into a book? I am truly baffled that this is the quality of a book to be published. It is a disservice to anyone seeking information, and the time of Muslims just being happy to be included has long passed. Books written this poorly keep stereotypes about Islam and Muslims as other and backward going. I am very disappointed.
The book is not sourced, and I have sent an email to the publisher asking for corrections in future reprints.
