Zaman Kids Series (The Story of Al-Andalus, The Story of the Ottoman Empire, Muslim Heroes & Muslim Heroines for Kids) by’Issa Meyer illustrated by Robi Dalimonte
Sep6
These gorgeous Islamic history books aimed at kids middle grade and up, should probably be reviewed individually, but their organization, presentation, and style are similar that even with different content, I’m opting to comment on them collectively.
- Thick 8.5 x 12 hardback covers and sturdy binding, check!
- 64 glossary full color illustrated pages, check!
- Backmatter that includes a map, glossary, and information about Islamic Dynasties, check!
- Visual appeal and writing style aimed at kids, check!
- Sourcing and bibliography…….NOPE!
I’m baffled, truly. These books are made with intention, the Ottoman Empire and Story of Al-Andalus feature information about the times and places being discussed, with a “Did You Know” pullout section, and feature key individuals in the same manner Muslim Heroes and Muslim Heroine books have, with an image of the person, an “ID” card, “Famous Words” along with the text broken up into key sections. So why is there no sourcing regarding where the information was acquired or some proof that a knowledgeable person has checked the contents. There is nothing about the author either, providing no reassurance to the reader that the information is coming from someone who is qualified to present it and attest to the accuracy.
Since I am not knowledgeable to give my opinion on the information contained, I will not. And since I am praising the visual presentation of the books, I will add a criticism that the titles on the bindings read backwards. I’ve included inside pictures from “The Story of Al-Andalus for Kids” for you to determine your own thoughts on accuracy, presentation, and utility.
