Chris Van Hollen: The Pakistan-Born Senator Too Principled for Pakistan’s Powerful
There is a peculiar distinction between loving a country and loving those who govern it. The distinction is elementary, yet authoritarian establishments have extraordinary difficulty understanding it. They expect affection for a nation to translate into obedience to its rulers, and historical attachment into permanent diplomatic indulgence.
Senator Chris Van Hollen has committed the unforgivable offense of refusing this arrangement.
The Maryland Democrat, born in Karachi, Pakistan, and now challenging Chuck Schumer for Senate Democratic leadership following the party’s midterm victories, represents something of an embarrassment to Pakistan’s ruling establishment. Here is a senior American politician with deep familial connections to Pakistan, genuine affection for its people, and growing influence in Washington.
One might imagine Islamabad celebrating.
Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah
Alhamdulillah, we’re at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.
The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small.
Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you’re supporting without thinking about it.
Instead, Van Hollen has become precisely the sort of American politician Pakistan’s rulers would prefer not to encounter: one who knows the country too well to mistake its government for its people.
And, more inconveniently, one prepared to say so.
A Son of Pakistan, a Critic of Its Rulers
Van Hollen’s connection to Pakistan is neither recently discovered nor politically manufactured. Born in Karachi in 1959, he belonged to an American diplomatic family whose professional universe encompassed South Asia, the Middle East, and the Muslim world.
His father, Ambassador Christopher Van Hollen Sr., served in senior State Department positions and as ambassador to Sri Lanka and the Maldives. His mother, Edith Eliza Van Hollen, was deeply involved in American foreign-policy and intelligence work concerning South Asia.
For the younger Van Hollen, Pakistan was never merely another country appearing in congressional briefing papers. It belonged to the geography of his childhood.
Yet his affection for Pakistan has not prevented him from condemning political repression, democratic erosion, and the treatment of former Prime Minister Imran Khan.
In August 2025, he wrote to Pakistan’s ambassador in Washington expressing grave concerns about arbitrary arrests, restrictions on political expression, and democratic backsliding.
Apparently, being born in Pakistan does not oblige an American senator to pretend that political prisoners are imaginary.
The Van Hollens and My Father
For me, the Van Hollen name carries an additional, distinctly personal resonance.
Long before Chris Van Hollen entered the Senate, his father inhabited the Washington policymaking world in which my late father, Dr. Mumtaz Ahmad, spent a formative period of his intellectual life.
The setting was the 1980s, when the Iranian Revolution, Soviet occupation of Afghanistan, and resurgence of Islamic political movements made Islam and politics a central preoccupation of Washington.
My father, then pursuing his doctorate at the University of Chicago and working at Brookings, was drawn into this world because he possessed something many American specialists lacked: intimate knowledge of the societies they were struggling to comprehend.
Ambassador Van Hollen brought decades of diplomatic experience to discussions of South Asia and the Middle East. He was no armchair strategist discovering the Muslim world through intelligence summaries.
The two developed a close intellectual relationship and friendship.
Another central figure in this milieu was Professor John L. Esposito, one of my father’s closest friends and himself a longtime friend of Ambassador Van Hollen. All three belonged to an overlapping intellectual community engaged in serious debates about Islam, politics, and American power.
Neither the elder Van Hollen nor his wife operated outside the ideological framework of American imperial power. They were career functionaries of its foreign-policy establishment. But this was also an era when Washington contained diplomats, analysts, and scholars of formidable intellectual seriousness, deeply immersed in the histories, languages, and political complexities of the regions they studied.
One could challenge their political assumptions without questioning their knowledge.
That distinction has become considerably harder to sustain in contemporary Washington.
My childhood unfolded around these intellectual circles. Van Hollen and Esposito were among the names circulating through our household, part of the world through which I came to understand Washington’s complicated relationship with the Muslim world.
The Arabists and Their Disappearance
The elder Van Hollens belonged, broadly speaking, to a diplomatic tradition associated with what Washington once called the Arabists.
These officials were hardly anti-imperial revolutionaries. Yet their familiarity with Arab and Muslim societies made them less susceptible to the ideological caricatures favored by powerful constituencies in Washington.
Their supposed offense was sympathy.
Pro-Israel hardliners distrusted Arabists who took Palestinian grievances seriously. Some India-centered South Asia specialists similarly resented perspectives that accorded Pakistan, Afghanistan, and political Islam importance independent of India.
These were distinct disputes, but they exposed a common intellectual pathology: understanding Muslims on their own terms could itself become grounds for suspicion.
From the 1990s onward, the ascendancy of neoconservative ideologues and increasingly influential hardline pro-Israel networks helped marginalize this older diplomatic tradition. Regional expertise was progressively subordinated to ideological conformity, particularly concerning Israel, Iran, and the wider Muslim world.
The consequences were spectacularly visible in the disasters of American Middle East policy.
Washington acquired more experts capable of explaining why Muslim societies needed American intervention, and fewer whose knowledge might have complicated the decision to intervene.
Apparently, knowing the region too well had become something of a professional liability.
An Establishment Democrat Who Refused Establishment Silence
Van Hollen did not emerge from the insurgent progressive generation challenging the Democratic Party’s orthodoxies.
He belongs to an older political establishment historically constrained by powerful donors, institutional discipline, and an exceptionally narrow permissible debate about Israel.
Yet his criticism of Israel’s conduct in Gaza, American weapons transfers, and Washington’s selective application of human-rights standards has placed him increasingly alongside younger progressive Democrats.
His significance lies in challenging the assumption that governments receiving American support should enjoy immunity from scrutiny.
That principle applies to Israel.
It also applies to Pakistan.
His leadership challenge to Schumer therefore matters beyond an internal Senate contest. It reflects a wider struggle over the entrenched interests and ideological habits defining Democratic foreign policy.
John Esposito, the American expert and writer on Islam, passed away in summer 2026.
John Esposito and the Price of Principle
Van Hollen’s moral consistency recalls that of Esposito, whose friendships with both my father and the senator’s father make the parallel especially poignant.
Esposito spent decades challenging hostile Western representations of Islam. Pakistan honored him with a prestigious civilian award and repeatedly welcomed him as a distinguished guest.
Yet he was profoundly disturbed by Pakistan’s descent into authoritarian repression, particularly the treatment of Imran Khan and the assault on democratic freedoms.
One of my final exchanges with him concerned an international petition demanding medical transparency and humane treatment for Khan.
Despite his longstanding ties to Pakistan’s establishment, Esposito proudly informed me that he had signed it.
His disappointment was unmistakable. A country he had spent decades defending against Western caricatures was witnessing precisely the abuses of power he had consistently challenged elsewhere.
For Esposito, intellectual integrity did not expire when the perpetrators of repression happened to be Muslim rulers.
Pakistan Is Not Its Establishment
Van Hollen and Esposito represent something increasingly uncommon in Washington’s dealings with Pakistan: an understanding of the country extending beyond its ruling elites and immediate strategic usefulness.
Whether Van Hollen becomes Senate majority leader or remains an influential senator, his importance to Pakistanis will hardly depend upon an official congratulatory message from their embassy.
His inconvenient habit of defending democratic rights makes diplomatic flattery rather difficult.
My father’s generation knew the elder Van Hollen and Esposito as men who took the Muslim world seriously. Esposito demonstrated what that seriousness demanded when Pakistan descended into repression. The younger Van Hollen now confronts a similar test in the political arena.
There is a certain historical symmetry in this.
The elder generation sought to understand societies American power too often reduced to strategic abstractions. The younger Van Hollen insists those societies cannot be reduced to the governments claiming to represent them.
Pakistan’s rulers may resent him precisely because he refuses to confuse their fortunes with those of Pakistan.
But that is not evidence that he has turned against the country of his birth.
It is evidence that he understands the difference between standing with a people and standing with those who rule them.
And in an age when powerful men demand loyalty while offering repression, that distinction is not merely admirable.
It is indispensable.
[Disclaimer: this article reflects the views of the author, and not necessarily those of MuslimMatters; a non-profit organization that welcomes editorials with diverse political perspectives.]
Keep supporting MuslimMatters for the sake of Allah
Alhamdulillah, we’re at over 850 supporters. Help us get to 900 supporters this month. All it takes is a small gift from a reader like you to keep us going, for just $2 / month.
The Prophet (SAW) has taught us the best of deeds are those that done consistently, even if they are small.
Click here to support MuslimMatters with a monthly donation of $2 per month. Set it and collect blessings from Allah (swt) for the khayr you’re supporting without thinking about it.